Where to Find All of the Best Pizza on Hilton Head

Here at Old Town Bluffton Inn, we understand that when a craving hits, it hits hard! Sometimes, you just need a slice of pizza. That’s why we compiled a list of the best spots for pizza on Hilton Head! This easygoing island is just a few miles away from the town of Bluffton, so delicious pies are never too far from reach. Keep reading to discover our favorite pizza places, then check out our Vacation Guide for more local insight!

See the Guide

3 of the Best Places to Enjoy Pizza on Hilton Head

Fat Baby’s Pizza and Subs

If you’re looking for pizza, subs, and other Italian favorites served in a no-frills atmosphere, look no further than Fat Baby’s! The owner’s philosophy—”If you’re not distracted by the decor, you must be here for the food”—says everything you need to know about this highly rated joint. Pete Bernstein’s mission was to create a place where friends and family come together over fresh, homemade pizza as a jukebox plays familiar tunes in the background. That’s exactly what he brought to life! Find this popular parlor at 1034 William Hilton Parkway.

Dough Boys Pizza

Another one of Hilton Head’s most beloved pizza places is Dough Boys Pizza! This cozy spot serves both classic and inventive pizza creations, so everyone in your crew will find a favorite here. In addition to mouthwatering, hand-tossed pies, the menu includes calzones, sandwiches, and more. You’ll love that there are also take-out and delivery options if you’re short on time. Put 1 New Orleans Road in your G.P.S. and look forward to satisfying that craving!

Il Carpaccio Ristorante

Ask any northerner and they’ll tell you: It’s incredibly difficult to find decent, thin-crust pies in the South. If you need a break from the high-traffic seafood spots, try Il Carpaccio Ristorante. The menu consists of traditional Italian favorites (sans lasagna or spaghetti and meatballs) in cozy, no-frills digs. Some even say it resembles family-owned spots they’ve visited in Italy. Find this restaurant at 200A Museum Street on Hilton Head.

Come Back to Rest and Digest at Old Town Bluffton Inn!Room 205 at Old Town Bluffton Inn

After sampling some of the best pizza on Hilton Head, come back to rest and digest at Old Town Bluffton Inn! We’re just a short drive away from all of Hilton Head’s best restaurants. Old Town Bluffton Inn is the newest, most luxurious lodging experience in the Lowcountry! If you’d rather walk off some of that pizza before snuggling up in your soft bed, step out of your beautifully appointed room and into the Promenade. You’ll love Old Town Bluffton’s walkable shops, galleries, and other coastal charms. Simply select one of our uniquely decorated rooms, book it on our site, and get ready to experience some of the finest amenities around! Looking for more Lowcountry dining options? You don’t even need a car to get to Bluffton’s best restaurants (including pizza places)—there are plenty within walking distance of the inn.

Excited for your future trip to the Lowcountry? Your first step should be to book a room at Old Town Bluffton Inn! We can’t wait to host you.